The lesson
Keep the standard pitch-deck slot labels and fill each slot with one plain claim, so the order does the persuading.
A Pitch Unfairly rebuild. The cover reads "Marry us in secret. End the feud by Thursday." above a "PRE-SEED" tag. Labeled slots follow: THE PROBLEM (a big 3 over "civil brawls"), THE SOLUTION (a feud-meter gauge with a Today / After the wedding toggle, reading 27 projected), WHY NOW, MARKET and TRACTION ("One balcony conversation. Very promising.").
Don't copy the jokes or the numbers, which are part of the story. Keep the eyebrow label over each headline and the habit of stating one claim per slide.