The lesson
Give each content piece a full-width piece of art with a small colored caption block, and treat the homepage as a gallery.
Each lead story is a wide collage or illustration with a solid caption panel at bottom left holding title, "Words by" byline, one dek and a topic label, such as "Against supplements" and "Roman love". Between stories sit "Get the best of WIP in your inbox" and "Get the print magazine". Smaller outlined cards list further essays.
Don't copy the collage style or the palette. Keep a consistent caption block, one dek per piece, and subscribe prompts placed among the stories.