The lesson
Run a competitor comparison as a disclosed, repeatable test with a published rubric, and let the rival win the rows it really wins.
Under the title and byline, a "Quick takeaways" box gives the verdict up front: Napkin scored 23 out of 30, Claude 21 out of 30, and the advice is "Use both." The body discloses "we make Napkin" and then lays out the test. It introduces a made-up firm, Hamlet and Hamilton Inc., quotes the prompt word for word, lists the models used, and shows a scoring table for Accuracy, Finding the Point, Visual Judgment, Memorability, Clarifying Questions and Editability. Sections then walk through "The First Pass," "Shaping the Presentation" and "Editing Afterwards" with product screenshots. A final score breaks out each criterion, including Accuracy: Napkin 4, Claude 5. A sticky sidebar offers "Try Napkin Slides for Free."
Don't copy the fictional company, the specific model settings or Napkin's scores, and don't run this format unless you are willing to publish the rows you lose. Keep the order: quick verdict, disclosure, fixed test setup, visible rubric, step-by-step walkthrough, per-criterion score, with a persistent trial CTA beside it.
Tell us what you want to make. We’ll talk through how to put these ideas to work for your brand.